Democracy for the Middle East
May 11, 2005Unrighteous Jew
Former Wall Street Journal reporter Laurel Leff picked up the Aushwitzgate story and wrote a book - Buried By The Times (Cambridge University Press).
Below is an excerpt from Sidney Zion's review.
The author, Laurel Leff, a professor of journalism and a former reporter for TheWall Street Journal, has done a fine job of research in the archives of the paper of record. Others could have done that, but nobody has. More important, she has brilliantly analyzed the reasons Arthur Hays Sulzberger, the German-Jewish publisher of The Times, brought Jewish self-hatred to a head long before the rubric gained popularity.
Think of it as the greatest legacy of Reform Judaism. As we wrote a couple of years ago:
Rather than taking inspiration from the particularist practices refined over centuries that enabled closeness to G-d, or identifying with the divinely promised return of Israel's children to their homeland, Reformism (as invented by Abraham Geiger in Hamburg and brought to New York by then publisher Adolph Och's father-in-law, Isaac Mayer Wise) turned its hopes instead toward "high-culture." Seen in this light it should come as no surprise that The Times frequently runs stories about "miraculous" events taking place at the Metropolitan Opera but finds the only actual miracle taking place in broad view today - the return home of the Jewish people to worship G-d on His holy mountain - to be a non-story.
When The Times defines the battle-lines of the American culture war as "normative us" versus "fundamentalist them", it is worth remembering the evangelical reformist origins of this ostensible norm, and that the oxymoron constructed by grafting Jewish identity to the denial of the divinely revealed nature of The Bible was invented out of whole cloth.
Perhaps it is because they come as a matched set in Ochsian secularism that our religiously oriented President has no tolerance for moral relativism or anti-Zionism. Traditional Zionism as embodied in the writings of Yehuda Halevi and the Psalmist is the ultimate expression of America's "Judeo-Christian" tradition where the rules of existence find their source above.
While American secularism can hardly be blamed on the German reform movement (its roots are multiple and span centuries of European history), because of its influence on the owners of The Times one has to wonder if the first shot of today's culture war wasn't fired in Hamburg, and whether in the final analysis, the war is only important to the extent that it impacts the future of Zion. The battle to separate society from G-d will continue to be waged by the descendants of Rabbi Isaac Mayer Wise and their "newspaper of record", and in the fateful years to come, Americans will continue to ponder whether they are for G-d and Zion, or The New York Times. Jewish-Americans, however, will be choosing between secularism and survival.
Home . Posted by Editor at May 11, 2005 07:39 PM . DFME's new internet address is www.dfme.org
Comments on this post:
Send to a friend
Post a comment
Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)
(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)